These "rankings" make absolutely no sense. How could you possibly place Danny W. over Charlie Ward or even Chris Weinke? Obviously we are factoring in pro career here, so why isn't Eric Crouch higher? They concede that Dayne broke Ricky Williams' mark, but Ricky is #2 and Dayne is way down there? Why is Charles Woodson so high up? Cuz he ran back a punt in a big game? Are there ANY objective criteria used here?
5 comments:
There is no way Ron Dayne has had a worse career than Rashan Salaam or Andre Ware. Charlie Ward didn't even play in the NFL. He was a NY Knick!
UIC Badger
I will admit that Barry Sanders had a greater career than Ron Dayne. But it isn't over until it is over and anything can happen. Go Big Red!
UIC Badger
These "rankings" make absolutely no sense. How could you possibly place Danny W. over Charlie Ward or even Chris Weinke? Obviously we are factoring in pro career here, so why isn't Eric Crouch higher? They concede that Dayne broke Ricky Williams' mark, but Ricky is #2 and Dayne is way down there? Why is Charles Woodson so high up? Cuz he ran back a punt in a big game? Are there ANY objective criteria used here?
I meant "we are NOT factoring in pro career"
I will give you may rankings based on college only not pro- which I beleive is what the "criteria" is here!
Post a Comment