My quick rankings of the last 20 H.T. winners, before Troy:

20. Gino Torreta
19. Rashaan Salaam- I'm sure that I am being persuaded by his awful career with the Bears, but Ki-Jana Carter of Penn State probably deserved it more that year.
18. Chris Weinke-barely beat Josh Heipel
17. Danny Wuerffell- this may be low for him, but no way he should be #8!
16. Vinny Testaverde- if the vote was after the Fiesta Bowl, he would have lost.